Albion Hotel, 47 Botchergate
Anglers' Inn, Shaddongate
Barley Stack, Rickergate
Bay Horse Hotel
Bee Hive, Brunton Place
Bird-in-Hand, 5 Castle Street
Black Bull, Annetwell Street
Blue Bell, Rickergate
Blue Bell, Scotch Street
Board Inn, Paternoster Row
Bricklayers' Arms Inn, John Street
Bush Hotel, Victoria Viaduct
Caledonian Hotel, 17 Botchergate
Caledonian Inn, 6 and 7 English Damside
City Commercial, 57 English Street
City Spirit Vaults, 58 and 60 Fisher Street
Coach & Horses, 44 and 46 Blackfriars Street
Commercial Hotel, 27 Botchergate
County Hotel, Court Square
Crown Hotel, 94 and 96 Botchergate
Crown Inn, 19 Henry Street
Crown Inn, 10 Corporation Road
Crown & Anchor, Crown and Anchor lane
Crown & Mitre, 4 English Street
Cumberland Hotel, 22 Botchergate
Cumberland Wrestlers' Hotel, Currock Street
Deaken's Vaults, 51 Botchergate
Denton Inn, 110 Denton Street
Dog & Bull Inn, Peascod's Lane
Drove Inn, 1 Rickergate
Duke of York Stores, 48 Shaddongate
Duke's Head, 8 Corporation Road
Durham Ox, 27 Rickergate
Earl Grey, 151 Botchergate
Farmers' Arms, 9 St. Cuthbert's Lane
Fish Inn, 7 Ferguson's Lane
Fish & Dolphin, 2 St. Cuthbert's Lane
Fox & Hounds, 25 Rickergate
Friar's Tavern, 1 Devonshire Street
George & Dragon, 41 Rickergate
Globe Inn, Bridge Street
Globe Spirit Vaults, 59 Scotch Street
Goliah Inn, Crown Street
Golden Fleece, Solway Street and Corporation Road
Golden Fleece, St. Nicholas Street. David Allan has told me that this is now the Carlisle South-End Constitutional Club.
Golden Lion, St. Nicholas Street and Princess Street
Great Central Hotel, Victoria Viaduct
Green Dragon, Newtown
Hare & Hounds, 28 Botchergate
Hole-in-the-Wall, 2 and 4 St. Alban's Row
Horse & Farrier Inn, Raffles
Howard's Arms, 16 Lowther Street
Joiners' Arms Inn, Church Street
Jovial Sailor, 34 Caldcoates - [named for the nearby Canal Basin].
Linton Holme Hotel, Lindisfarne Street
Lion and Lamb Hotel, Lion and Lamb Lane
Liverpool Arms, 1 Bewley's Court, English Street
London and North-Western Railway Inn, James Street
Lord Brougham, Henry Street
Lorne Arms, 30 Shaddongate
Lowther Arms, St. Cuthbert's Lane
Malt Shovel, 2 Rickergate
Maltsters' Arms, John Street
Masons' Arms Inn, 19 South John Street
Milbourne Arms Hotel, 150 Milbourne Street
Moulders' Arms Inn, Currock Street
Nelson Bridge Hotel, Denton Crescent
New Inn, Mount Street Court
North British Railway Inn, Newtown Place
Northumberland Arms, 76 Botchergate
Oddfellows' Inn, Crown Street
Old Anchor, 39 Bridge Street
Old Bush Inn, Old Bush Lane
Old King's Head, Fisher Street
Old Queen's Head Hotel, St. Alban's Row
Ordnance Arms, Finkle Street
Otter Inn, 11 Drovers' Lane
Petteril Bridge Inn, Brunton Place
Pheasant Inn, Church Street
Pine Apple Vaults, 104 English Street
Plough Inn, 16 and 18 Caldcotes
Prince of Wales Hotel, Denton Street
Queen's Inn, 128 Botchergate
Railway Hotel, 104 London Road
Railway Tavern, 37 Botchergate
Red Lion Hotel, 11 Botchergate
Rising Sun, 7 and 9 Scotch Street
Rose & Crown, Lowthian's Lane
Royal Oak, 38 Bridge Street
Samson Inn, 55 London Road
Saracen's Head, Irishgate
Scotch Arms, 20 Rickergate
Shakespeare Tavern, St. Cuthbert's Lane
Ship Inn, 15 Rickergate
Spinners' Arms, 57 Milbourne Street
Spread Eagle, English Street
Sportsman Inn, 1 Heads Lane
Three Cannons Inn, Three Cannons Lane, Scotch Street
Three Crowns Hotel, 77 English Street
Three Crowns, 33 Rickergate
Turf Hotel, Race Course
Victoria Hotel, 89 English Street
Waggon & Horses, 1 Bridge Street
Wellington Hotel, English Street
Wheat Sheaf, Rickergate
White Ox, St. Nicholas Street
William James Inn, Willow Holme
Wool Pack Inn, 79 Milbourne Street
Wrestlers' Arms Inn, 27 Annetwell Street

In addition, there were (un-named) beer houses at Boundary Road, 4 Fusehill Street, 5 Orchard Street, 11 Rickergate, and 87 Union Street.